Eur 40 electrodialysis stacks for the demineralization of cheese whey.

Dairy

WHEY DEMINERALIZATION PROCESSES

 

In the dairy industry, whey is obtained from the manufacturing of cheese and casein. There is a high demand for demineralized whey for many applications in human and cattle feed: these include instant formula (baby food; min. 90 % demin.), confectionary, baking, meats, etc. Depending on the use for the end product, the demineralization process has tbe tailored taking intaccount the complete composition of the raw whey: this includes the ash profile and the equivalent acid content. Thus, the optimum demineralization processes will be different for wheys produced from two types of cheese, even if these belong to the same cheese category.

 

In the case of cheese whey, there are two main grades of whey:
  • Sweet whey with a titrable acidity below 0.16 % or a pH above 6.0, from cooked cheeses
  • Acid whey with a titrable acidity above 0.4 % or a pH below 4.0, from soft, fermented, and cottage cheeses.
In manufacturing, the whey obtained after coagulation with HCl or H2SO4 has a titrable acidity between 0.4 and 0.45 %.

 

With more than 20 operating systems worldwide, Eurodia / Ameridia has a unique expertise in whey demineralization processes, either internally developed or licensed form close partners. In accordance with our general process development philosophy, the optimum process for each dairy customer might combine several technologies adapted to its specific product: these include electrodialysis reversal (EDR), ion exchange resins (IER), and nanofiltration (NF). For instance, nanofiltration is not attractive if used alone for any demineralization rates above 35 % because of the high losses of lactose and divalent ions: therefore, NF could be useful as a pretreatment or postreatment step. Similarly, ion exchange resins are not economically attractive when used alone because of the high volume of effluents, the high running cots, and the heavy pollution load. For more details about the use of nanofiltration only to demineralize whey, please go also to the Technologies Section/ Nanofiltration of this website.

 

Following, are some general guidelines for the expected optimized overall demineralization process for sweet whey:

 

 

SWEET WHEY DEMINERALIZATION

Method to be used depends on the required demineralization rate:

 
DEMINERALIZATION RATE (ON ASHES)
FEED
30%
50-70%
90%
DILUTED SWEET WHEY
6% DS
nanofiltration
ion exchange resins
+
nanofiltration
electrodialysis
+
ion exchange resins
+
nanofiltration
PRECONCENTRATED SWEET WHEY
18-24% DS
electrodialysis
electrodialysis
ion exchange resins
+
electrodialysis

Eurodia's design principles for a whey demineralization plant:

  • Achieve the demineralized whey specifications with the lowest operating costs and the most cost effective investment.

  • Maintain the quality of the valuable product (proteins) by avoiding microbiological development and thermal shocks (by operating at acidic pH as much as possible).

  • Keep the dry solid and valuable product yields as high as possible.

  • Reduce the volume of waste effluent as well as the pollution load.

  • Design the demineralization process taking into account the downstream process steps (i.e. evaporation, standardization, spray drying…) to optimize their operating and capital costs.

  • Optimize the choices of technology, materials, and instruments.

  • Look for easy maintenance.

  • Design to meet FDA and 3A requirements.

EXAMPLE

6 % DS SWEET WHEY DEMINERALIZATION FOR INSTANT FORMULA RUNNING COSTS in €/kg DS

WHEY DEMINERALIZATION PERMANENT IMPROVEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY

1.ELECTRODIALYSIS

  • Proprietary spacers specifically designed to dramatically reduce the internal leakage.

  • Thus :

  • Minimizes valuable products losses

  • Lowers pollution load even after 10,000 hours of operation

  • Improves the current efficiency and the power consumption

  • Reduces the water consumption.

  • Large range of spacers available to adapt the technology to the product

  • Different thicknesses depending on of DS content and viscosity

  • Different materials (all FDA approved grade) to operate at temperatures as high as 60°C

  • Different types of netting to optimize flows and lower pressure drops.

  • Proprietary ion exchange membranes (NEOSEPTAâ) manufactured by TOKUYAMA CORPORATION

  • Longest membrane life

  • All components are Food Grade

  • Organic fouling resistant

  • Metallic or graphite long lasting electrodes designed to operate in the current reversal mode (edr)

2. ION EXCHANGE RESINS AND COLUMNS

  • Specific ion exchange resins developed by RESINDION (MITSUBISHI CHEMICAL GROUP)

  • Strong cation gel type with high DVB content to improve the selectivity of resins when used as softeners before ED (SODIUM PROCESS® patented by the SAFIR Company).

  • Adsorption of protein and complexed salts is dramatically reduced.

  • Strong anion resins of special grade to be used with the above-mentioned strong cation resins in mixed beds (density, granulometry, swelling)

  • Weak cation resins (carboxylic) adaped to reduce the divalent cations and adjust the pH.

  • Weak anion resins with low swelling, no adsorption of proteins, and high capacity for phosphorous removal.

  • Technology of IER columns

  • Proprietary distributors

  • Cost effective regarding feed distribution and chemicals (regenerants) consumption

  • Adapted to resins swelling (if low).

  • Easy to move when increasing resins volume for capacity increase

  • Allowance for 100 % resin bed expansion.

3. EASY MAINTENANCE AND OPTIMIZED HYDRAULIC PIPING

  • ED stacks can easily be handled, disassembled and reassembled for on-site maintenance (in less than 2 hours per stack).

  • Rod electrodes that can be replaced within a few minutes (while hours are necessary for flat electrodes).

  • Easy access to all key components (pumps, valves, instruments).

  • Selection of reliable instruments for non-stop operation.

  • Short hydraulic piping for both ED and IER to optimize brine, chemicals, water and energy consumption.

  • Specifically designed valve manifolds are installed to avoid any risk of streams contamination (feed/product, product/chemicals etc...)

  • The on-line factor of our demineralization plants is usually higher than 96 -98%.

EXAMPLE

SWEET WHEY DEMINERALIZATION FOR INSTANT FORMULA

 


Table 1

Raw material composition, sweet whey analysis

Raw material to process/day

400 000 L/d

408 840 kg

Total solid

6.30%

25 757 kg

Density

1.0221

1.0221

Processing time per day

16 h/d

 

Annual production time

250d/year

 

Inlet temperature

4°C

 

Note : Material balance is expressed in true proteins + NPN, and not in total proteins.

 

Client data (or literature data)

RAW MATERIAL

SWEET WHEY FROM CHEESE MAKING

CLIENT'S DATA

%

Solid/Day

Equivalents

Equivalents

Molecular

 

 

 

cations

anions

weight

 

 

 

 

 

(equivalent)

PH

6.5

 

 

 

 

Density (abacus).

1.0221

 

 

 

 

Solids

6.300%

25 757 kg

 

 

 

Total protein

13.250%

3 413 kg

 

 

 

Nitrogen from casein.

0.040%

10 kg

 

 

120 mg/L

Whey proteins (estimated)

9.765%

2 515 kg

 

 

 

NPN (as Nitrogen)

0.540%

139 kg

 

 

6,38

Ash

8.900%

2 292 kg

 

 

70,5

Lactose

74.400%

19 163 kg

 

 

 

Fats

1.100%

283 kg

 

 

 

Ca++

0.625%

161 kg

8 049 eq.

 

20

Mg++

0.146%

38 kg

3 134 eq.

 

12

Na+

0.970%

250 kg

10 863 eq.

 

23

K+

2.100%

541 kg

13 869 eq.

 

39

NH3+

0.380%

98 kg

5 438 eq.

 

18

Fe++

0.010%

3 kg

92 eq.

 

27.93

Cu++

0.010%

3 kg

81 eq.

 

31.77

Cl-

2.163%

557 kg

 

15 694 eq.

35.5

P

0.600%

155 kg

 

4 989 eq.

31

NO3-

0.030%

8 kg

 

125 eq.

62

S

0.165%

42 kg

 

1 328 eq.

32

CO3--

 

 

 

 

30

Lactic acid

1.400%

361 kg

 

4 007 eq.

90

acetic acid

0.196%

50 kg

 

841 eq.

60

Citric acid

1.800%

464 kg

 

2 634 eq.

176

Other 1

 

 

 

 

 

Other 2

 

 

 

 

 

Checking

 

24 764 kg

41 525 eq.

29 618 eq.

 

Other, by difference

96.10%

993 kg

- 41 525 eq.

- 29 618 eq.

 

 

 

Table 2

Raw material composition, standard sweet whey

Adjusted data

%

Solid/Day

Equivalents

Equivalents

Molecular

 

 

 

cations

anions

weight 1

 

 

 

 

 

equ

PH

6.5

 

 

 

 

Density (abacus).

1.0221

 

 

 

 

Solid

6.30%

25 757 kg

 

 

 

Total protein

13.25%

3 413 kg

 

 

 

Nitrogen from casein.

0.04%

10 kg

 

 

 

Whey proteins (estimated)

9.76%

2 515 kg

 

 

 

NPN (as Nitrogen)

0.54%

139 kg

 

 

6.38

Ash

8.28%

2 133 kg

 

 

70.5

Lactose

76,88%

19 801 kg

 

 

 

Fats

1.10%

283 kg

 

 

 

Ca++

0.63%

161 kg

8 049 equ

 

20

Mg++

0.15%

38 kg

3 134 equ

 

12

Na+

0.97%

250 kg

10 863 equ

 

23

K+

2.10%

541 kg

13 869 equ

 

39

NH3+

0.38%

98 kg

5 438 equ

 

18

Fe++

0.01%

3 kg

92 equ

 

27.93

Cu++

0.01%

3 kg

81 equ

 

31.77

Cl-

2.16%

557 kg

 

15 694 equ

35.5

P

0.60%

155 kg

 

4 989 equ

31

NO3-

0.03%

8 kg

 

125 equ

62

S

0.17%

42 kg

 

1 328 equ

32

CO3--

 

 

 

 

30

Lactic acid

1.40%

361 kg

 

4 007 equ

90

acetic acid

0.20%

50 kg

 

841 equ

60

Citric acid

1.80%

464 kg

 

2 634 equ

176

Other 1

 

 

 

 

 

Other 2

 

 

 

 

 

Checking

100,00 %

25 757 kg

41 525 equ

29 618 equ

 

Other, by difference

 

 

- 41 525 equ

- 29 618 equ

 

Total mass

 

408 840 kg

 

 

 

Water

 

383 083 kg

 

 

 

Total volume

 

400 000 L/d

 

 

 

 


Table 3

Inlet/ Outlet balance of demineralization process

STANDARD SWEET WHEY

Adjusted analysis

%

Solid/Day

DEMINERALIZED WHEY OUTLET (non standardized)

%

Solid/Day

PRODUCTION

PH

6.5

 

PH

5.5

 

 

Density

1.022

 

Density

1.089

 

 

Solid

6.30%

25 757 kg

Solid

21.62%

22,335 kg

86.72%

Total protein

13.25%

3 413 kg

Total protein

13.86%

3,096 kg

90.73%

Nitrogen from casein.

0.04%

10 kg

Nitrogen from casein.

 

 

 

Whey proteins (estimated)

9.76%

2 515 kg

Whey proteins (estimated)

11.10%

2,479 kg

98.55%

NPN (as Nitrogen)

0.54%

139 kg

NPN (as Nitrogen)

0.43%

97 kg

69.62%

Ash

8.28%

2 133 kg

Ash

0.37%

82 kg

3.84%

Lactose

76.88%

19 801 kg

Lactose

86.84%

19 395 kg

97.95%

Fats

1.10%

283 kg

Fats

1.26%

280 kg

98.94%

Ca++

0.63%

161 kg

Ca++

0.00%

0 kg

0.18%

Mg++

0.15%

38 kg

Mg++

0.00%

0 kg

0.18%

Na+

0.97%

250 kg

Na+

0.04%

9 kg

3.65%

K+

2.10%

541 kg

K+

0,09%

20 kg

3.65%

NH3+

0.38%

98 kg

NH3+

0.02%

4 kg

3.66%

Fe++

0.01%

3 kg

Fe++

0.00%

0 kg

0.21%

Cu++

0.01%

3 kg

Cu++

0.00%

0 kg

0.21%

Cl-

2.16%

557 kg

Cl-

0.05%

11 kg

2.01%

P

0.60%

155 kg

P

0.08%

17 kg

11.12%

NO3-

0.03%

8 kg

NO3-

0.00%

0 kg

1.01%

S

0.17%

42 kg

S

0.00%

0 kg

0.00%

Lactic acid

1.40%

361 kg

Lactic acid

0.01%

2 kg

0.59%

acetic acid

0.20%

50 kg

acetic acid

0.00%

0 kg

0.63%

Citric acid

1.80%

464 kg

Citric acid

0.00%

0 kg

0.00%

Total weight

 

408,840 kg

Total weight

 

103,289  kg

 

Water

 

383,083 kg

Water

 

80,954 kg

 

Total volume

 

400,000 L/d

Total volume

 

94,831 L/d

 


Table 4

Demineralized whey analysis

COMPOSITION OUTLET

%

Solid /Day

Equivalents Cations

Equivalents Anions

Molecular weight (Equivalent)

pH

5.5

 

 

 

 

Density (abacus)

1.0892

 

 

 

 

Solid

21.62 %

22 335 kg

 

 

 

Total protein

13.86 %

3 096 kg

 

 

 

Nitrogen from casein.

 

 

 

 

 

Whey proteins (estimated)

11.10 %

2 479 kg

 

 

 

NPN (in Nitrogen)

0.43 %

97 kg

 

 

6.38

Ash

0.37 %

82 kg

1 161 eq.

1 161 eq.

70.5

Lactose

86.84 %

19 395 kg

 

 

 

Fats

1.26 %

280 kg

 

 

 

Ca++

0.00 %

0 kg

14 eq.

 

20

Mg ++

0,00 %

0 kg

6 eq.

 

12

Na++

0.04 %

9 kg

397 eq.

 

23

K+

0.09 %

20 kg

507 eq.

 

39

NH3+

0.02 %

4 kg

199 eq.

 

18

Fe++

0.00 %

0 kg

0 eq.

 

27.925

Cu++

0.00 %

0 kg

0 eq.

 

31.77

Cl-

0.05 %

11 kg

 

315 eq.

35.5

P

0.08 %

17 kg

 

555 eq.

30.974

NO3-

0.00 %

0 kg

 

1 eq.

62

S

0.00 %

0 kg

 

0 eq.

32

Lactic acid

0.01 %

2 kg

 

24 eq.

90

Acetic acid

0.00 %

0 kg

 

5 eq.

60

Citric acid

0.00 %

0 kg

 

0 eq.

176

Checking

100.00 %

22 335 kg

1 122 eq.

900 eq.

 

Other, by difference

0.00 %

 

38 eq.

261 eq.

 

Total weight

 

103 289 kg

 

Water

 

80 954 kg

 

Total Volume :

 

94 831 L/d

 


Table 5

Volume and Composition of Effluents

VOLUME AND COMPOSITION

Daily Quantities

Volume

450m3/d

Solids

4 330 kg

Solids from chemicals

908 kg

Solids from product

3 422 kg

Total proteins (N x 6,38)

317 kg

Nitrogen from casein

10 kg

Whey proteins (estimated)

37 kg

NPN (as Nitrogen)

42 kg

Ash

2 052 kg

Lactose

406 kg

Fats

3 kg

Ca++

161 kg

Mg++

38 kg

Na+

347 kg

K+

521 kg

NH3+

94 kg

Fe++

3 kg

Cu++

3 kg

Cl-

1 641 kg

P

137 kg

NO3-

8 kg

S

42 kg

Lactic Acid

358 kg

Acetic Acid

50 kg

Citric acid

464 kg


Table 6

Consumables and Utilities

CONSUMABLES

UNIT

DAY

YEAR

€/DAY

€/YEAR

Hydrochloric  acid

Kg

1 126 kg

281 405 kg

546.00

136,803

Compressed air

Norm. M3

294 Nm3

73 614 Nm3

6.22

1,559

ULTRASYL 54

Kg

25.00 kg

6 250 kg

76.10

19,056

ULTRACLEAN

Kg

3.49 kg

873 kg

9.97

249

FRESH WATER

M3

 5 m3

1 273 m3

0.43

108

CITY WATER

M3

8 m3

2 021 m3

0.46

117

DEMIN. WATER

M3

120 m3

30 004 m3

13.18

3,302

ELECTRIC ENERGY

KWh

3 823 kwh

955 721 kwh

200.30

50,178

COOLING ENERGY

Frigorie

3,50E+06kfies

8,74E+08 kfies

95.75

23,977

CAUSTIC SODA

Kg

185 kg

45 166 kg

67.60

16,928

STEAM

Tonne

16.2 t/d

4 055 tons

202.42

50,686

Special Maintenance ( resins, membranes ….)

 

770.03

192,814

TOTAL :

 

 

 

1,988.46

495,777

 

 

 

 

 

 

SAVINGS ACHIEVED FROM CONCENTRATION

 

833.13

208,283

TOTAL INCLUDING SAVINGS

 

 

1,155.33

287,494

 

Demin. product. Dry matter

22 335 kg

Cost per kg of dry matter for demin. product

 

Savings from concentration not included

0.09 €/Kg

Savings from concentration included

0.05 €/Kg



About Us | Contact Us | Industries | Technologies | Products | News